How we score providers

Ordinal, evidence-typed and transparent. Every level has a written definition, a weight, a source URL and a capture date. Missing information is shown as "not documented" and excluded from the band; it never counts as zero. The map combines documented criteria into delivery scope and verifiable rigor.

Criteria and weights

Price transparency · weight 20%

Do you know what you will pay before talking to sales?

  1. Site explicitly says contact for quote
  2. Publishes only a starting price, without what it includes
  3. Publishes a range or named packages with partial inclusions
  4. Publishes fixed package prices with inclusions and exclusions listed
  5. Level 3 plus online checkout or a public standard contract, or price confirmed by a third party

Scope of deliverables · weight 20%

What comes out finished: FDD, agreement, manual, financial model, registrations?

  1. Strategy only; no documents delivered
  2. One core document (FDD only, or manual only)
  3. FDD plus franchise agreement (the legal minimum to sell)
  4. Level 2 plus operations manual plus at least one of financial model, state registration, training, or sales/marketing
  5. Level 3 plus trademark and state registrations, itemized deliverables and a public sample or verified case

Verifiable legal competence · weight 20%

Is the FDD signed by a licensed attorney with registration-state and Item 19 experience?

  1. Documents generated without attorney review, or unnamed in-house lawyer
  2. Says it works with attorneys, without naming a firm or person
  3. Names a partner attorney or firm, or explicitly recommends review by the client's franchise attorney
  4. Named attorney, licensed (state or bar number), franchise-law practice page, registration states mentioned
  5. Level 3 plus third-party recognition in franchise law, or substantive Item 19 and renewal publications with filings declared

Franchise experience and focus · weight 15%

How long, how many systems, and is franchising the main practice?

  1. Franchising is one of several areas; under 2 years; no cases
  2. Franchising as declared focus, under 5 years, no named cases
  3. 5 or more years, or 10 or more named clients on the site
  4. 10 or more years and a named portfolio of 25 or more systems, or systems launched declared with a date
  5. Level 3 confirmed by a third party (public FDDs naming the firm, supplier rankings, verified reviews, press)

Post-launch support and annual compliance · weight 10%

Is there a named annual FDD update, state renewals, or continuing counsel, and at what price?

  1. Site says delivery is one-time, no updates
  2. Mentions generic ongoing support
  3. Annual FDD update or state renewals offered as a named service
  4. Level 2 with a published price or recurring plan and the compliance calendar explained
  5. Level 3 plus a compliance portal, continuing counsel with SLA, or third-party review mentioning renewals

Documented timeline · weight 10%

How fast is delivery, and is it written down?

  1. Site says it depends; no commitment
  2. Over 26 weeks
  3. 13 to 26 weeks
  4. 2 to 12 weeks
  5. 1 week or less, written on a product page or terms

Third-party reputation · weight 5%

Rankings, directories, verified reviews, complaints.

  1. Unanswered BBB complaints, regulatory action, or relevant public litigation
  2. Testimonials on the provider's own site only
  3. Verified reviews on an independent platform (10 or more at 4.0 or higher) or confirmed IFA membership
  4. Level 2 plus an industry ranking or trade-press citation
  5. Legal or consulting band ranking (Chambers, Legal 500, Best Lawyers) or 50 or more verified reviews at 4.5 or higher

Evidence rules

Bands

Band = weighted mean of the scored criteria only. A provider needs at least 5 of 7 criteria documented to receive a band; otherwise it is "Not classified". Band A additionally requires two T or R sources, otherwise it is capped at B.

See the scorecard for all providers.

Corrections

Use the source on each provider profile to check a score or listing. To suggest a correction, email [email protected] with the listing and supporting source.

Change log